Mattress Protector vs Mattress Topper - What's The Difference?

Mattress Protector vs Mattress Topper - What's The Difference?

 Written By: Michal Szlas - Founder and CEO of Otty Sleep

 

Mattress protectors and mattress toppers serve very different purporses. 

This blog post is your ultimate guide to understanding these two key sleep products, helping you make an informed decision for your bed.

What is a Mattress Protector?

A mattress protector is an extra layer designed to protect the mattress from spill stains and allergens. 

Fitted around your mattress in the same way a fitted sheet is, a mattress protector ensures your sleep isn't disturbed by allergens. Y

You can find products such as the OTTY hypoallergenic mattress protector, tailored to cater to allergy and asthma sufferers.

What is a Mattress Topper?

A mattress topper adds an extra layer of comfort to your existing mattress, improving your night sleep.

A mattress topper can an vary significantly in terms of thickness and materials. Crafted from memory foam, latex, or even feathers, choosing the right topper is crucial. You can also find unique memory foam toppers infused with natural materials, like the OTTY Bamboo & Charcoal topper, which add extra benefits to your sleep, as well as an extra layer of comfort.

Learn more with our comprehensive guide to mattress toppers.

Key Differences Between Mattress Toppers and Protectors

These two accessories, while seemingly similar, serve distinct purposes and offer unique benefits.

Function and Purpose

  • A mattress topper is primarily designed to change the feel of your mattress. It can either soften a mattress that's too firm or add firmness to one that's too soft.
  • A mattress protector's role is protective. It's a barrier against liquids, allergens, and in some cases, even bed bugs. The primary purpose here is to protect your mattress - to extend its life by shielding it from spills, stains, mites, and more.

 

Material and Design

  • Mattress toppers are typically composed of several materials, ranging from memory foam to our durable bamboo. It's common for them to have a more luxury feel, promoting a warmer, plush sleep environment. Timely shedding of these layers can effectively extend the service life of your mattress.
  • Mattress protectors are less about enhancing the feel of your mattress and more about creating a barrier. They are chiefly made from waterproof materials for protection against spillages, allergens, and bed bugs. The design is also simpler, mostly serving a practical function.

Price

  • Mattress toppers tend to be more expensive as they fulfil a luxury function by adding increased comfort to your bed.
  • Mattress protectors are more utilitarian in purpose and therefore tend to have a lower price point.

 

Choosing Between A Mattress Protector and Mattress Topper

Both have their unique benefits and can significantly enhance your sleep experience. However, understanding the key differences between these popular mattress accessories is crucial to making an informed decision.

Consider Your Personal Needs

Are pressure relief and comfort your priorities? A memory foam mattress topper might be the perfect fit. They add an extra layer of softness and contour to your body for ultimate relaxation.

Opting for either doesn't exclude the other. You can always choose both, tailoring them to your needs. Just ensure to balance comfort with protection.

Evaluate Your Current Mattress

To make an informed choice between mattress toppers and mattress protectors, have a think about your current mattress.

Does it still have strength in its support, or has it lost its firmness? A topper, typically made from foam or latex, can provide additional comfort and extend the lifespan of your mattress.

If your mattress still has a good backbone but lacks a comfortable surface, a topper could be the solution you need. It provides an extra layer for pressure relief, which is exceptionally beneficial for those who sleep on their sides or have joint pain issues.

On the other hand, if your mattress is still relatively new but you're concerned about potential damage, then a good mattress protector is what you should consider.

Think About Your Budget

When selecting between a mattress topper and a mattress protector, it's crucial to consider your budget. The price of these accessories can vary considerably, depending on their features and materials.

It's well-known that mattress protectors tend to be less expensive. Having a thinner layer and a primary function of providing protection against spills, they invariably come at a lower price point.

On the other hand, mattress toppers are typically more pricey. Toppers, whether it's a popular foam mattress or a latex one, are meant to provide pressure relief and comfort, which escalates their cost.

Benefits of Using a Mattress Topper

A mattress topper is a versatile sleep product that offers a plethora of benefits. It's not just an extra layer on your bed, but a tool that can significantly enhance your sleeping experience.

Enhanced Comfort and Support

A mattress topper, despite simply being an extra layer, can significantly boost the comfort and feel of your bed. This is often due to materials such as memory foam or latex, chosen for their exceptional pressure relief and support capabilities.

The foam mattress topper is particularly popular because it contours to your body, providing an individualised night’s sleep experience. This added layer transforms a rigid sleep product into a comfortable bubble of rest.

Apart from firmness or softness modifications brought by the topper, it can also provide extra pressure relief on key points such as hips and shoulders. This can be a game-changer for side sleepers who typically experience such problems.

Extended Mattress Lifespan

A mattress topper not only enhances the comfort and feel of your bed, but can extend its lifespan. Adding this extra layer of protection helps safeguard your mattress from wear and tear.

Investing in a mattress topper is therefore a smart decision for anyone keen on prolonging the longevity and quality of their bed. By shielding from typical wear and tear, it promises both an improved slumber experience and a money-saving solution.

 

Benefits of Using a Mattress Protector

The benefits of using a mattress protector are numerous, from safeguarding against allergens and bed bugs to preventing stains and spills. It's a simple addition to your bedding that can make a significant difference in the quality and longevity of your mattress. 

Protection Against Allergens and Bed Bugs

For individuals grappling with allergies and asthma, a mattress protector can be a game-changer. These protectors, especially the hypoallergenic ones, act as barriers against a multitude of allergens such as dust mites and pet fur.

Prevention of Stains and Spills

The use of a mattress protector helps prevent stains and spills directly on your bed. Inadvertent accidents such as splashes of coffee, wine, or even unexpected liquid discharges can have damaging effects on the quality and longevity of your mattress.

By using a high-quality protector, you protect your mattress, ensuring it stays in its original pristine condition for an extended period. 

If you've got stains on your mattress topper, check out our guide on how to clean a mattress topper.

Summary and Key Takeaways 

The choice between a mattress protector and a mattress topper largely depends on your personal needs and preferences.

Whether you're seeking an extra layer of comfort, pressure relief, or a shield against allergens and spills, both accessories offer unique benefits.

Remember, a good mattress protector can extend the life of your mattress, while a topper can enhance the feel of your bed.

 

Back to blog